I’ve been a fan of Weezer since their early 90’s, so I was excited to hear they have a new album coming out soon. I loved their fist album (the blue album) – I thought it was one of the best alternative/rock albums of the early 90s. Pinkerton is my favorite – the riffs on that album are heavy and dark, which matches Rivers’ darkest and most introspective lyrics (and really, songs about child-rape just aren’t going to be light pop songs). I thought there was a lot to like about the green album (“hash pipe,” “islands in the sun”). Maladroit was heavy and underappreciated. I didn’t love “Make believe” but it had a few rocking tracks.
I’ve listened to the new album (The Red Album) a few times now, and it’s very disappointing. The tunes are more pop than rock, and even worse, they’re just boring. There’s the obligatory whiney self-indulgent “I’m sorry if I hurt you” tune (“The angel and the one”), a few catchy if pretentious mtv aimed pop songs (“The greatest man that ever lived, pork & beans”) but very little that rocks. It’s 10 tracks and 41 minutes of completely forgettable radio schlock.
My theory is that every time Weezer makes a dark, metal infused album (Pinkerton, Maladroit), it tanks commercially, and Rivers overreacts and makes pop music aimed for mtv/radio play. This is the second such album following their last heavy album, Maladroit (including 2005’s “Make believe”) and it follows a pattern. It’s as if Rivers is upset that his introspective/heavy albums don’t get recognized, and he evidently wants commercial recognition, so he writes songs aimed for the mtv crowd. It’s almost like he’s trying too hard to be popular.
I have a rule that I will overlook one bad album from a band that I’ve appreciated in the past. This is Weezer’s second in a row, and the red album is worse than Make Believe, which at least had a few decent tracks. If they go back to form they established with the blue album, pinkerton, the green album or maladroit on their next project, I’ll be back as a Weezer fan, but if they continue to write pop songs aimed at teenagers, then I’ve heard about enough.
Fav tracks: Troublemaker is the only track on this album I liked.
Posted in Uncategorized
Tags: red album, weezer
Recent Comments